docs: add session-expiration-policy decision entry + CURRENT-STATE summary
Ninth and final commit in the session-expiration-policy series. - .ai/DECISIONS.md: new entry documenting the two-window model (3d idle / 14d absolute defaults), per-account override design, grandfather strategy, error-detail taxonomy on the wire, and the rejected alternatives (idle-only / absolute-only / hard SECRET_KEY cutover / Loose preset / reveal-on-Custom UI / modal-stays-open for scope=all). Includes consequences and follow-up tickets. - CURRENT-STATE.md: 'Recently shipped' entry summarizing the 8-commit series across backend (migration, claims, enforcement, two endpoints) and frontend (page, hook, toast, banner, modal), referencing the plan + design-review file. Pending after this commit: open PR, merge, file the per-user device-list + super-admin global-ceiling follow-up issues per plan §9. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
@@ -13,6 +13,34 @@
|
|||||||
|
|
||||||
---
|
---
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
## 2026-05-13 — Session expiration policy: 3d idle / 14d absolute defaults + per-account override
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
**Context:** User report: "I login to ResolutionFlow and never have to log back in." Investigation found refresh tokens at `REFRESH_TOKEN_EXPIRE_DAYS=7` with JTI rotation (`security.py:36`) — every `/auth/refresh` minted a fresh 7-day window. Net effect: a sliding 7-day session with no absolute cap. Visit once a week, logged in forever. Acceptable for pilot but not for MSP buyers whose SOC2 / cyber-insurance auditors require enforced session timeouts. Required for the same Phase O launch readiness as the other gates already in flight.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
**Decision:** Two-window model snapshotted into the refresh JWT at login. Defaults to Strict (3-day idle, 14-day absolute), bounded by env-var system min/max. Per-account override via two new `accounts` columns (NULL = use system default). Owner-only `GET/PATCH /accounts/me/security` endpoint with effective-value validation (partial-override case caught at the app layer because the DB CHECK can't see Settings). Sibling `POST /accounts/me/security/revoke-sessions` for `all|others`-scoped bulk revocation. Frontend: Strict/Standard/Custom presets, active-users list (name + email + last-login-ago), differentiated SessionExpiryToast (idle = warning amber with "Stay signed in" → `/auth/refresh`; absolute = info cyan, informational only), cyan info-tone banner on `/login?reason=session_expired`, auto-redirect after scope=all bulk-revoke. Error-detail taxonomy on the wire: `session_expired_idle`, `session_expired_absolute`, `invalid_refresh_token`. Grandfather path: legacy refresh tokens (no `auth_time` claim) get one free rotation under the new policy. Atomic-revoke-then-check on `/auth/refresh` so absolute-expired tokens can't be replayed.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
8 commits on `feat/session-expiration-policy` branch (`92fa3bc` → `c7cd711`), ~1300 LoC backend + frontend including 28 backend tests. Plan + design review at `docs/plans/2026-05-13-session-expiration-policy.md` (initial design score 4/10 → final 9/10 via `/plan-design-review`; 7 design decisions locked).
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
**Rejected:**
|
||||||
|
- **Idle-only or absolute-only enforcement.** Idle without absolute is the current broken state (sliding forever). Absolute without idle is too strict — kicks users out daily.
|
||||||
|
- **Hard cutover on deploy (SECRET_KEY rotation).** Forces every pilot to log in again immediately; high support cost. Grandfather path is friendlier and adds ~50 lines of code.
|
||||||
|
- **Distinguish `session_revoked_by_admin` from `invalid_refresh_token` on the wire** for users whose sessions were killed via bulk-revoke. Requires tracking revocation reason per `refresh_tokens` row. Not worth the complexity for v1 — affected users see they're logged out, same as any other revoke.
|
||||||
|
- **Per-user device list with per-device revoke.** Refresh tokens don't carry device/user-agent metadata today. Account-wide bulk revoke covers the breach-response use case; per-device is a follow-up if pilots ask.
|
||||||
|
- **"Loose" preset (90d).** Strict default suggests we shouldn't ship a one-click loose option. Owners who want a loose policy can use Custom and own the choice explicitly.
|
||||||
|
- **Always-required `idle_minutes`+`absolute_minutes` (XOR-NULL invariant).** Forces owners who only want to override idle to also re-declare the absolute window, leaking the system default into account data. Partial overrides allowed; validated at the app layer against current defaults.
|
||||||
|
- **Reveal-on-Custom UI for the minute inputs.** Hidden-by-default-reveal-on-radio shifts page layout when Custom is selected. Always-visible-but-disabled is more stable and previews the Custom interaction.
|
||||||
|
- **Modal-stays-open-success-state for scope=all bulk-revoke.** User preferred auto-redirect-with-toast (more standard SaaS pattern); the toast acts as the success acknowledgment before /login loads.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
**Consequences:**
|
||||||
|
- "Logged in forever" is fixed. Every user sees a hard 14-day re-auth at minimum (3-day idle in practice for typical usage).
|
||||||
|
- Account owners get a complete self-service surface for policy + bulk session control. New `/account/security` route, owner-gated.
|
||||||
|
- Audit-log entries on both mutations: `account.session_policy_update` and `account.sessions_revoked_bulk`. SOC2-ready.
|
||||||
|
- Frontend `idle_expires_at` + `absolute_expires_at` flow through the entire auth surface (`Token`, `OAuthCallbackResponse`, `authStore`, persistence). `useAuthSessionExpiry` hook is the single source for "is the session about to end."
|
||||||
|
- Future improvements (filed as follow-ups in plan §9): per-user device list (requires `refresh_tokens.last_used_at` column), super-admin global ceiling UI, per-user policy. None block current shipping.
|
||||||
|
- Cyan info-tone banner on `/login` is the first of its kind in the app; sets precedent for future neutral system messages.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
---
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
## 2026-05-07 — Per-email allowlist (`INTERNAL_TESTER_EMAILS`) for self-serve soft cutover
|
## 2026-05-07 — Per-email allowlist (`INTERNAL_TESTER_EMAILS`) for self-serve soft cutover
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
**Context:** Phase O Task 46 ("internal validation pass") needed a way to exercise the full self-serve flow against the prod backend before flipping `SELF_SERVE_ENABLED=true` for everyone. The plan doc described the mechanism but the backend support was never built — flagged in `SESSION_LOG.md` as a code blocker. Stripe live-mode setup is also gated on having a working internal-tester path in prod test mode.
|
**Context:** Phase O Task 46 ("internal validation pass") needed a way to exercise the full self-serve flow against the prod backend before flipping `SELF_SERVE_ENABLED=true` for everyone. The plan doc described the mechanism but the backend support was never built — flagged in `SESSION_LOG.md` as a code blocker. Stripe live-mode setup is also gated on having a working internal-tester path in prod test mode.
|
||||||
|
|||||||
@@ -14,6 +14,8 @@ Self-serve signup backend (Phase 1) and frontend (Phase 2) are merged. Cutover (
|
|||||||
|
|
||||||
## Recently shipped (post-0.1.0.0)
|
## Recently shipped (post-0.1.0.0)
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
- **2026-05-13 — `feat/session-expiration-policy` (open)** Session expiration policy series — 8 commits, fixes the "logged in forever" bug and adds owner-side controls. Migration `b269a1add160` adds `accounts.session_idle_minutes` + `session_absolute_minutes` (NULL = use system default, defaults Strict 3d/14d via `Settings.SESSION_*_MINUTES_DEFAULT`). Refresh-token JWT carries `auth_time` + `idle_max` + `abs_max` claims (seconds) snapshotted at every login entry point (`/auth/login`, `/auth/login/json`, both OAuth callbacks). `/auth/refresh` enforces absolute cap (`now >= auth_time + abs_max` → 401 `session_expired_absolute`), atomic-revoke-then-check prevents replay. Error-detail taxonomy on the wire distinguishes `session_expired_idle` / `session_expired_absolute` / `invalid_refresh_token`. New owner-only `GET/PATCH /accounts/me/security` returns `{idle_minutes, absolute_minutes, effective_*, *_min/max, active_users}` with audit logging on PATCH. `POST /accounts/me/security/revoke-sessions` bulk-revokes refresh tokens for the account (`scope: "all" | "others"`), audited. Frontend: new `/account/security` page (Strict/Standard/Custom presets, active-users list with name + email + last-login-ago, count-aware revoke buttons + confirmation modal), `useAuthSessionExpiry` hook + top-of-app `SessionExpiryToast` (differentiated by idle vs absolute), cyan info-tone banner on `/login?reason=session_expired`. Plan + design review in `docs/plans/2026-05-13-session-expiration-policy.md` (initial 4/10 → 9/10 via `/plan-design-review`). 28 backend tests; tsc clean. Pending: open PR, merge, document follow-up issues (per-user device list, super-admin global ceiling UI).
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
- **2026-05-07 — PR #164 (open)** Plan taxonomy reconciliation + `INTERNAL_TESTER_EMAILS` allowlist. Marketing surface (PricingPage, Stripe products) used `Starter / Pro / Enterprise` while backend was on `free / pro / team`, leaving `plan_billing` unseeded and `BillingPlan` schema accepting a literal that violated the FK. Migration `4ce3e594cb87`: rename `team` → `enterprise` in `plan_limits`, add `starter` row (caps interpolated between free and pro: `max_trees=10`, `sessions=75`, `ai=15/mo`), defensive update of any subscriptions on the `team` slug. Code rename across schemas, `Subscription` paid-plan checks, admin endpoints, and frontend `useSubscription`. Resource visibility (`Tree.visibility='team'`, `StepLibrary.visibility='team'`) is a separate domain and intentionally untouched. New `backend/scripts/sync_stripe_plan_ids.py` — idempotent upsert of `plan_billing` rows from Stripe products by exact name match, picks active monthly recurring price, leaves annual fields NULL by design. Test-mode `plan_billing` populated for all 3 tiers in dev. Phase O Task 46 allowlist: `INTERNAL_TESTER_EMAILS` env var (comma-separated) bypasses `SELF_SERVE_ENABLED=false` for specific authenticated users — `Settings.is_self_serve_active_for(email)` centralizes the check; `/config/public` returns `self_serve_enabled=true` for allowlisted authenticated callers; `/auth/register` allows allowlisted emails to register without invite code. New `get_current_user_optional` dep for endpoints that work both anonymous and authed.
|
- **2026-05-07 — PR #164 (open)** Plan taxonomy reconciliation + `INTERNAL_TESTER_EMAILS` allowlist. Marketing surface (PricingPage, Stripe products) used `Starter / Pro / Enterprise` while backend was on `free / pro / team`, leaving `plan_billing` unseeded and `BillingPlan` schema accepting a literal that violated the FK. Migration `4ce3e594cb87`: rename `team` → `enterprise` in `plan_limits`, add `starter` row (caps interpolated between free and pro: `max_trees=10`, `sessions=75`, `ai=15/mo`), defensive update of any subscriptions on the `team` slug. Code rename across schemas, `Subscription` paid-plan checks, admin endpoints, and frontend `useSubscription`. Resource visibility (`Tree.visibility='team'`, `StepLibrary.visibility='team'`) is a separate domain and intentionally untouched. New `backend/scripts/sync_stripe_plan_ids.py` — idempotent upsert of `plan_billing` rows from Stripe products by exact name match, picks active monthly recurring price, leaves annual fields NULL by design. Test-mode `plan_billing` populated for all 3 tiers in dev. Phase O Task 46 allowlist: `INTERNAL_TESTER_EMAILS` env var (comma-separated) bypasses `SELF_SERVE_ENABLED=false` for specific authenticated users — `Settings.is_self_serve_active_for(email)` centralizes the check; `/config/public` returns `self_serve_enabled=true` for allowlisted authenticated callers; `/auth/register` allows allowlisted emails to register without invite code. New `get_current_user_optional` dep for endpoints that work both anonymous and authed.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
- **2026-05-06 — PR #163** Seed test users marked email-verified. Fixed seeded users showing the email verification banner in dev/test, blocking flows that gate on `email_verified=True`. Squash-merged into main as `dad5e1f`.
|
- **2026-05-06 — PR #163** Seed test users marked email-verified. Fixed seeded users showing the email verification banner in dev/test, blocking flows that gate on `email_verified=True`. Squash-merged into main as `dad5e1f`.
|
||||||
|
|||||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user